The pattern hem is actually straight across the bottom but it comes out a good 6 inches longer at center front in a long curve. That giant dart seems to be the problem. I am playing around with the top on my dressform. The back on which I made a narrow back adjustment, fits perfectly.
This is what I came up with. I took out a 3" dart on either side of the dart, the one on the right is perpendicular to the center front and the one on the seft is perpendicular to the waist, stretch line. This still isn't enough but if I take it up any more there I'll no longer have the drape at the hem.
I figure that I will hem the center deeper. Only because I love this style am I willing to put so much effort into a simple knit top!
The cowl bottom top? Not willing to go the extra mile for it. It's way too long, the underarm is too low as well (they all use the same back) and as you can see, the neckline is also lower than the illustration. I added a dart to this top but it's too low and if I was going to make this I'd raise it up. But I'm not. It's just not right for me.
One thing I learned from this experience is that making a muslin for a knit is quick and easy. It took longer to trace the pattern than to sew it up. I always avoid muslins for knits because knits are so much more expensive than a bolt of muslin and they are all so different in stretch and recovery. However, I have a lot of knits in my stash that I am never going to use (this one was very thin and it wasn't expensive) that I can use them up making muslins and reduce my stash at the same time.
so sad to hear about this pattern. I just cut all the pieces apart last night and was hoping this one would be a winner.
ReplyDeleteMermie
what a shame, but I am glad you didn't waste any good fabric. I also use cheap knits to muslin knit patterns.
ReplyDeleteWhat a shame! You were smart to muslin it first. After the jeans and now this maybe you need one of Carolyn's "quickie" projects.
ReplyDeleteTalk about frustrating! The concept of the draped bottom is really neat. Too bad the pattern doesn't reflect the photo image. Good luck with this one!
ReplyDeleteGood you did a muslin first, but what poor pattern drafting. You at least learned that the pattern is not right for you. Time to move on to something else, perhaps a tnt top?
ReplyDeleteMy one HP experience was so terrible I don't think I'll ever try them again. :( I'm glad these were only muslins!
ReplyDeleteI would give up on the HP pattern but not give up on the style. What you interests you is that nice drapey pleat. So... trace a t-style top pattern, full front, that you already have. using the drawing as an inspiration slash from one shoulder to the hem and spread about 5" (just a guess as you don't want the giant dart again). I would probably slash nearly on grain as I would not want the stretch of the bias added into the mix.
ReplyDeleteI really LOVE HotPatterns Tops and Pants...but this style did not work out for me either. Maybe because I am so short? Who knows...but it reminds me of the unfortunate years I had to wear a colostomy bag.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I consider myself lucky that out of the countless different tops, tunics, and blouses I've made with HotPatterns...only this one has been a disappointment :)
Thanks for the thorough review! I was just about to trace off this pattern. I haven't had great luck with Hot Patterns, but I love their illustrations! There's so much potential!
ReplyDeleteWell, I'll raise the underarm and cut a size or two down and see what happens.
It sounds like your knit may have been a rayon blend. Very drapey, so appropriate for that pattern, but the weight of it is such that you really need to compensate in every vertical direction. A cowl neck I made last year in a lightweight cotton turned out perfect, in a rayon blend it was almost past my bra. So the problem is probably not the pattern..
ReplyDelete